top of page

Flounder: Against the Tide, 2024
                                                                                                                                                     June 19th 2024

Oxstalls

Oxstalls campus, dance studio 1: video recording of mirrored movement

​

The work started off with a simple aim:  make whiteness absurd and undermine its neutrality.

​

Through this work I found that ‘the real’ is always contingent and relative, and we can witness this dynamic across theatre aesthetics and in the kinds of movement that emerges from working‑class areas such as care homes, assisted living, last provision schools, and the unrehearsed but repeated bodily practices that resemble shamanic labour. A working-class repetition not for the arts but for another and to sustain oneself. This movement is a knowledge system.

​​

Care work — I was often on a three‑person shift; understaffed meant all bodies were unsafe. A balancing act: my skeleton and their personal care. To prevent skin breakdown or neglect, my body always came second. My bones wear those care homes’ managerial decisions, those government cuts, today. The economic restraint threaded through everything, including my body. The unequal distribution did permanent damage to my spine. My body will never move with middle‑class cadence, with scripted perfection. And maybe that’s an undervalued uniqueness? The bodily knowledge accumulated through care work became one of the many encounters influencing dancing-with (Starkey, 2023–2026), contributing to its understanding of movement as a mode of knowing rather than simply a vehicle for expression. Take somatophobia and Western rationalism: it divorces the body from the mind. But the body is one. It suggests knowledge accrued in the body is low knowledge, if knowledge at all. But what if the body as a whole structure breaks ‘script’, the status quo that keeps knowledge middle‑class and ableist? Why does communication have to be verbal or written? Which shuts the door on anything other than itself, a self‑feeding system that reproduces knowledge but does not produce. What if the marginalised body can offer something outside the script? 

​

So when a white, middle‑class male supervisor told me to “rehearse”, I knew he couldn’t comprehend what he was doing by offering that advice — the epistemic erasure he was asking for. The time in a dance studio I wasn’t afforded financially; I was in the middle patch of land I stood on. Eurocentric expectations of art placed onto a working‑class body — even at PhD level — revealed a bizarre, inescapable colonialism. When he advised me to work with a professional dancer, I knew the supervision with this person was only going to erase political dimensions and flatten my difference into a colonial, white sameness. Blanket dominance that wipes difference out. When I asked whether that was to promote difference(s), he paused and added: work with a Black dancer, grease him up and cover him in white paint. His abrupt directive was my confirmation. At that point, I knew this wasn’t an ethical provocation; it was an abuse of power. I knew neither I nor my project was safe with this person.

​

After these supervisory comments. I did not attend another supervision with this person. The harm, the knowing that future harm could take place, created an ethical obligation, a responsibility to act. After a long-winded complaint process, the university quelled the OIA through unenactable recommended remedies. One included the potential for a supervisor swap. The supervisor, the complaint officer named suggested in the stage 2 outcome, had already left. 

​

The space that could not be bridged, and therefore he chose to flatten it ...

​

My body wears stress from class discrimination; it holds the tension deep in the muscle and bone of economic hardship, from the various disparate places that shaped me. ​That knowledge made the movement, made it more singular, unexpected. I treated this not as a “with” or “without,” a deficit; I am not a victim of my history. I would choose my working-class knowledge; I would choose to help rather than neglect people in every lifetime, in every universe. It has accosted me bodily knowledge that has made my understanding and movement unique. This is not a sad story; this knowledge has produced movement that middle-class aesthetics cannot replicate. I understood/understand it as a liberation. Words not yet spoken for. And the potential to challenge whiteness, which gains its power from its invisibility, as Richard Dyer reminds us in his book White, 2nd edition (2017), and its neutrality, as Nirmal Puwar argues in her book Space Invaders, its refinery, need for control, dominance, among other things. Nell Irvin Painter shows us how whiteness was historically crafted as the site of purity and bodily discipline, a kind of aesthetic hygiene. I did not move in this way...I could not afford to. My working-classness ruptured the theatrics. I witnessed this most clearly in my latest iteration of Flounder: Against The Tide (2024). It spoke to Lacanian theory; the mirror stage directly: the clown was the ego, the stabilising image the subject clings to for coherence. But movement revealed a limit in Lacan’s claim. Once the ego appeared, it did not hold. Through movement, a second formation emerged, an inner being, an untamed feral agent. Lacan theorises the production of the ego, not its undoing. My work showed that the ego can surface and then fracture, giving way to a fugitive, non‑egoic presence. This split between the mirrored ego and the feral agent marks the point where the work challenges Lacan: not by rejecting the mirror stage, but by showing how movement exposes the ego’s fragility, especially when whiteness’s aesthetic regime loses its grip.

​

​

​

​

​

​

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

What emerged instead was feral, an alchemy that breaks the theatrical contract. A fugitive formation, an expression that surfaces when whiteness’s aesthetic regime collapses.

​

​This collapse was expressed through superseding the theatrical, image and presence fall out of alignment. The sound followed suit. Instead of the expected Tchaikovsky, I spliced Mozart and Chopin abruptly, fracturing the internal logic of classical music. Dr. Liz Swift articulated the dissonance clearly: “I was expecting one thing and got another — I was expecting Tchaikovsky’s Swan Lake, then received Mozart, then suddenly Chopin. Was that intentional?”

 

"Absolutely, the edit had been created prior, and it was the one element that was not produced live. I edited it so that between the birth story the classical music weaves in and out of dimension, then once the listener believes that coherence is starting to form, it splinters off into another direction. That slipperiness and non-closure are intentional.” I created it through the editing, figuring out how an active live body would also simultaneously shift the visual and affective field. I also placed mint essence in glass jars around the room to clash with the blood that leaked out of my body. As menstrual bleeding is not a guarantee, I relied on moving image alongside my real-time body. The slight inconsistencies in the movement made the twins jarring and added to the slip between representation and the real.

​

Dr Liz Swift later followed with the comment: “I read your research paper and I find it interesting how you’ve incorporated Deleuze and Guattari’s rhizome within your performance art methodology.” What mattered in her observation was the recognition that the work structurally enacted a rhizomic form—something she could feel in the organisation and movement of the practice itself. Her comment confirmed that the methodology was affective: that its non‑hierarchical, proliferating structure was not only conceptual but materially present, perceptible, and operating through the work’s unfolding.

​​

I wanted to see if I could destabilise the sonic architecture that props up theatrical appearance, and from feedback it seemed to be effective.

​

​

​

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The audience could enter and exit at any time, which mattered. Within dancing-with (Starkey,2023-2026), encounterers are not positioned as passive recipients of a predetermined meaning. Instead, real-time liveness redistributes power, allowing meaning to emerge through differing encounters. It meant there was no fixed beginning, no privileged point of entry. Deleuze and Guattari describe the rhizome as a structure without hierarchy, without a single root, without a doorway that determines how you should move through it. Flounder: Against the Tide, 2024 operated in that same way. Viewers could encounter the work at any node — the clown, the birth story, the sonic rupture, the misaligned image — and each point functioned as a legitimate starting/exist place. To dismantle hierarchy and challenge hegemonic structures, I chose a non-hierarchical methodology/internal structure. Within dancing-with, no single element functions as an anchor. Screens, sounds, images, a real-time body moved sideways, diagonally, unpredictably. The clown, the birth story, the sonic fractures, the panting body: none of them behaved like a trunk. They surfaced as shoots, brief intensities that linked, broke apart, and re‑formed in the moment. The audience’s movement through the work wasn’t outside the structure; it evolved it. Their drifting and unpredictable entry and exit became part of the rhizome.

​

I explained earlier that it's an encounter; you can arrive at any time, but you can also leave at any time. For me, it was not theatre. Any sense of narrative slipped through my fingers like water. My body quivered, cried, and panted as I, too, lost grip of the clown. 

​

Through dancing-with, live art became rhizomatic because it didn’t ask the audience to follow a path. It asked them to inhabit a field where no dictatorial need for understanding existed; understanding was on one's own terms.

 

Meaning didn’t accumulate through narrative or coherence; it emerged through proximity, collision, spill, drift. Each splice in the music created a new line of flight. Each visual misalignment opened another route. Each shift in presence destabilised the previous one. The work kept multiplying its own logic, refusing to settle.

                                                                        

                                                                                             Reinventing the Rhizome 

​

Instead of a philosophical rhizome that exists on the page, I created a live rhizome that operates through body, sound, and affect. A rhizome that doesn’t just describe multiplicity but enacts it. A rhizome that doesn’t rely on metaphor but on the instability of whiteness’s aesthetic regime. When that regime collapses, what emerges is not chaos but a horizontal spread - a fugitive, feral network of relations that cannot be disciplined back into theatrical coherence.

​

The audience’s ability to enter and exit at any moment was part of the rhizomatic structure. They weren’t guided; they were implicated. Each person attached themselves to whichever node they encountered first or could encounter. They left with different configurations. The work didn’t offer a single reading because it didn’t have a single root. In that sense, Flounder Against the Tide, 2024 doesn’t just use the rhizome; it practices it decolonially. It shows how a rhizomatic method can be embodied, how it can destabilise whiteness not through critique alone but through structural refusal. It becomes a method of undoing: undoing coherence, undoing hierarchy, undoing the verticality whiteness depends on. What remains is the lateral spread, differing encounters, the fugitive formation, the feral line of flight.​

​

                                                                                 Dancing-with // Chalk & Cheese 

​

The rhizomatic structure of this piece emerges from the early articulations I developed in my initial research modules, when I first began sketching a rhizomatic performance art model. At the time, I referred to it as an embryo stage; s1513009 MR401 Performance Art - Resistance. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.16163077  - a tentative beginning, a root system forming. I now understand, through practice, that the rhizome has no centre, no privileged point of origin. In my lived experience and in my live art practice, it feels impossible to separate whether it germinated in one or the other, and I increasingly think the distinction is unnecessary.

Over time, the rhizome expanded through its own root system as I practiced, experimented, and allowed the methodology to shift. I sometimes name this approach dancing‑with—or dancing‑with and in—though I resist fixing it too firmly, because it alters with every work. The method remains fugitive, atemporal, relational, and in motion.

 

​This trial‑and‑error process was simultaneously experimental and a mode of discernment. It enables me to understand which functions of the practice are actively disrupting hierarchical knowledge systems by insisting on a non‑hierarchical structure. In doing so, the work challenges representational norms and specifically unsettles the colonial aesthetics that rely on stability, i.e firm representation from in historical depictions such as paintings, legibility - safety of knowing what it is, and closure. Through this rhizomic, relational method, I ask how such a system might generate decolonial aesthetics; ones that leak and refuse containment. And instead cultivate multiplicity, movement, and continual becoming.

​

Supervisor A noted that the effect was "perhaps even more emphatic" when the blood was shown in video form, contrasted with a live body moving through the empowering smell of mint.

​

This piece took 6 months of experimenting with sound, smell, imagery, whilst keeping the live element as raw as possible. 

​

​

​​​​​​

                                                                      ​​​​​

​                                     

​

​

​

​

 

Screenshot 2024-06-21 195901.png

Flounder:Against The Tide

Possibility/ies 

The feral agent remains in constant flux and becoming. There is no stable image for it. Any attempt at representation fails because the image cannot hold; its resolution betrays the very instability it seeks to contain. In this failure, the feral agent offers an alternative to positivist assumptions of knowledge as fixed, stable, and absolute.

Bodily presence:

Live body 

Filmed body 

People entering:

Dr. Liz Swift

People entering: Supervior A

Possibility/ies 

Dancing-with : Chalk and Cheese

Sound:

Splintered classical music; Mozart & Chopin. The absence of Tchaikovsky’s Swan Lake

Mother's working-class voice: telling the story of a messy birth.

 

One take recording, with natural bird sounds.

People existing:

I left in a bathrobe and sliders. And went to the showerroom. I didn't wait for an applause. And nobody knew when it was 'over'. I left that up to each person.

Taste: edible mints (mentos)

Possibilities 

Smells: 

Spearmint essence

Edible mints 

Blood, iron smell - patriarchy has marked it 'unclean.' When its a man's wound its religious, sacred. Biblical. When a woman naturally sheds it's 'gross', even though the stem cells in this blood is life-saving/life replemishing. I wanted to challenge and disrupt these Christian notions that make up white ideologies.

​​

Possibility/ies 

People existing:

Professor Ros Jennings

Professor Ros Jennings commented on the importance of the space itself and my body's occupation of it.  She was particularly interested in the body's movement through the installation,the way the work bounced between these elements without settling into any pattern. Her reading emphasised that the piece operated through movement, dispersal, and a spatial logic that resisted fixity.

She suggested I look further into liminality and metamodernism; as I remember it, this was connected to the work’s oscillation, its in‑between states, and its refusal to adopt a singular aesthetic position. What stayed with me was her recognition that the work’s affective force emerged from its spatial and multimodal instability - its refusal to resolve, its continual shifting.

​

Note: 

My wider philosophy is grounded in embodied, relational, and an alternative to positivist knowledge-making, where meaning emerges through live encounters. I do not consider practice and theory to exist separately; the work understands theory as something generated through practice, and practice as inherently theoretical. My refusal to treat the rhizome as a model reflects this commitment to non‑division: thinking happens through doing, and doing is already a form of thought. 

​​

​

References:

Chopin, F. 1833. Nocturne in B‑flat minor, Op. 9 No. 1. Paris: Maurice Schlesinger. 

Deleuze, G. & Guattari, F. 1987. A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia. Translated by B. Massumi. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. (Original French edition: 1980.) 

Dyer, R. 2017. White. 2nd ed. London: Routledge. 

Eyers, T. 2012. Lacan and the Concept of the “Real”. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. 

Kristeva, J. 1982. Powers of Horror: An Essay on Abjection. Translated by L.S. Roudiez. New York: Columbia University Press. 

Lacan, J. 1977. ‘The Mirror Stage as Formative of the Function of the I as Revealed in Psychoanalytic Experience’. In: Écrits. Translated by A. Sheridan. London: Routledge. 

Mozart, W.A. 1827. Serenade No. 13 in G Major, K. 525 (“Eine kleine Nachtmusik”). Offenbach am Main: Johann André. (Composed 1787.) 

Painter, N.I. 2010. The History of White People. New York: W.W. Norton & Company. 

Puwar, N. 2004. Space Invaders: Race, Gender and Bodies Out of Place. Oxford: Berg. 

Starkey, E. 2024. Flounder: Against the Tide. Live Art/research work. 

Tchaikovsky, P.I. 1900. Swan Lake, Op. 20. Moscow: Jurgenson. (Original score; composed 1875–1876.) 

​

​

bottom of page